Can you give an example of a time when you had to make a difficult technical decision? How did you make the decision?
- Dipankar Sarkar
- May 7, 2023
Sure, here’s an example of a difficult technical decision I had to make in my previous role as a tech lead:
Our team was working on a project that involved building a new feature for an existing software application. We were faced with a difficult technical decision regarding whether to use an existing third-party library for a critical component of the feature or to build the component from scratch.
On one hand, using the existing library would save us a significant amount of time and effort in development. However, we had concerns about the reliability and security of the library, as well as the long-term maintenance implications of incorporating a third-party component into our codebase.
After carefully evaluating the pros and cons of each approach, I decided that it would be best to build the component from scratch. This decision was based on several factors, including our need for greater control and flexibility over the component, concerns about the reliability and security of the third-party library, and our desire to maintain a clean and maintainable codebase.
To make this decision, I consulted with other members of the development team, as well as our product manager and stakeholders. I presented them with the options and the rationale for each, and we discussed the potential risks and benefits of each approach. Ultimately, we agreed that building the component from scratch was the best course of action.
This decision was not easy, as it involved a significant investment of time and resources. However, I felt that it was the right decision for the project and the long-term health of our codebase. Throughout the development process, we were able to maintain close communication with stakeholders, keeping them informed of our progress and the rationale behind our technical decisions.
As a result of this decision, we were able to build a high-quality, reliable feature that met our requirements and exceeded our stakeholders’ expectations. We also were able to maintain full control over the component, which made it easier to maintain and debug the codebase in the future.
In summary, when faced with a difficult technical decision, I believe it is important to carefully evaluate all of the available options and their potential risks and benefits. It is also important to involve other stakeholders and team members in the decision-making process to ensure that all perspectives are considered. Ultimately, the decision should be based on what is best for the project, the team, and the long-term health of the codebase.
Additionally, I believe that it is important to maintain a growth mindset and be open to new ideas and approaches. This can help to identify creative solutions to difficult problems and ultimately lead to better outcomes. Finally, I always strive to communicate clearly and transparently with all stakeholders throughout the decision-making process, ensuring that everyone is informed and understands the reasoning behind the final decision.
Overall, making difficult technical decisions is a challenging but important part of being a software tech lead. By carefully evaluating all of the available options, involving other team members and stakeholders, maintaining a growth mindset, and communicating clearly and transparently, I believe that it is possible to make informed decisions that ultimately benefit the project and the team.